Breaking the Silence: How Toxic Masculinity and Family Expectations Impact Men’s Mental Health in India

Breaking the Silence: How Toxic Masculinity and Family Expectations Impact Men’s Mental Health in India

The Unseen Crisis

The conversation around mental well-being in India has rightly gained momentum in recent years, yet a critical demographic—men—continues to struggle in silence. Often referred to as a “silent epidemic” in research circles, male mental health is an urgent public health concern that demands immediate attention (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025). As the world observes events like Men’s Health Month and Father’s Day, it is imperative to move beyond surface-level acknowledgment and confront the deep-seated cultural and societal pressures unique to Indian men.

As the world observes events like Men’s Health Month and Father’s Day, it is imperative to move beyond surface-level acknowledgment and confront the deep-seated cultural and societal pressures unique to Indian men.

The gravity of this situation is underscored by alarming national statistics. According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data for 2022, men accounted for a staggering 71.8% of all suicide victims in India (NCRB, ADSI 2022). This male-to-female suicide ratio is one of the most pronounced gender disparities in global suicide figures. Furthermore, suicide is the leading cause of death for Indian men between the ages of 15 and 44 (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).

The escalating number of calls on national helplines, such as the government-backed Tele-MANAS, which crossed 2,00,000 calls within the first nine months of its launch (PIB, 2023), clearly demonstrates a burgeoning need for emotional support. This detailed exploration seeks to dissect the primary factors contributing to this crisis: the rigid structure of traditional masculinity and the immense burden of family expectations in a rapidly modernizing society.

The Culture of Strength: What is Toxic Masculinity?

Toxic masculinity is not about gender itself, but a set of rigid, harmful cultural norms associated with being a man, which enforce emotional restriction and discourage vulnerability. In the Indian context, this ideology is deeply ingrained from childhood, often manifesting in vernacular phrases that act as “emotional handcuffs” (YRG Care).

In the Indian context, this ideology is deeply ingrained from childhood, often manifesting in vernacular phrases that act as “emotional handcuffs”

The Mantra of Suppression: “Mard ko Rona Nahi Chahiye”

The pervasive Hindi phrase, “Mard ko rona nahi chahiye” (A man should not cry), is perhaps the most significant cultural edict shaping the emotional lives of Indian men. This adage is not merely advice; it is a fundamental pillar of traditional masculinity ideology (TMI) that dictates that a man must never show weakness or vulnerability (YRG Care; Levant, 2020).

  • Emotional Lockdown: Boys are conditioned to believe that sadness, fear, or emotional pain is equivalent to being “sissy stuff” or showing “no sissy stuff,” a key component of the Brannon Masculinity Scale (Levant, 2020). This results in a lifelong pattern of emotional repression—or “bottling up” emotions, as referred to by Kalpana Srivastava, a clinical psychologist—which eventually manifests as poor coping skills, irritability, and aggression (Feminism in India, 2024).
  • The Big Wheel and The Sturdy Oak: Traditional Masculinity Ideology (TMI) emphasizes concepts like “The Sturdy Oak” (men should never show weakness) and “The Big Wheel” (men must strive for successful achievement and respect) (Levant, 2020). These norms equate manhood with stoicism and success, making any failure—be it professional, financial, or personal—feel like a fundamental failure of their identity.
  • Childhood Conditioning and Adult Trauma: The socialization process of a boy teaches him that crying yields negative attention (ostracization, shaming, or being told to “man up”) while stoicism is praised (“You were so brave for not crying”). This gender role trauma (Levant, 2020) forces men to create a façade, leading to a profound sense of Gender Role Discrepancy—the psychological distress that arises from failing to meet these impossible male role expectations. The result is an emotional prison where men lose the capacity to identify, process, or communicate their inner distress effectively (YRG Care).

Family Responsibilities and Emotional Isolation

In a patriarchal society, the man’s role is intrinsically linked to his function as a “Provider” and “Protector.” This framework imposes intense pressures that significantly exacerbate mental health challenges.

The Burden of the Provider

The expectation to be the sole breadwinner and problem solver is a “pressure cooker” environment for Indian men (YRG Care). Whether they are agricultural workers in rural states or IT professionals in urban centres, the financial and occupational stress can be immense.

  • Economic Stress as a Direct Cause: Statistics tragically highlight this link. In 2022, out of all farmer/cultivator suicides nationally, 96% were male, a chilling figure reflecting the direct toll of economic instability and debt on the male provider identity (NCRB, ADSI 2022). Furthermore, married men face a disproportionately high suicide risk, with one study noting that in 2021, the suicide mortality rate for married men was three times higher than that for married women (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025). This suggests that the obligations tied to marriage, family, and financial stability act as significant risk factors.
  • The Emotional Rock: Men are often expected to be the “emotional rock” of the family. This means they must absorb the stress of others without expressing their own. This lack of reciprocal emotional exchange leads to emotional isolation, where their friendships remain in the “shallow end,” centred on activities rather than vulnerable, intimate sharing (YRG Care). The absence of a deep, supportive network means men often face their deepest struggles alone.

Societal and Life Stage Stressors

The distress is compounded at various life stages, driven by societal expectations of success:

Life Stage ExpectationMental Health Impact
Young Adulthood (18-29)Pressure to secure a high-status job (“The Big Wheel”) and maintain economic independence. Failure to achieve this can lead to feelings of shame and self-stigma, contributing to a rising suicide rate in this age group (up from 20 to 25 per 100,000 in India between 2014 and 2021) (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).
Middle Age (30-44)Peak pressure to manage career, service debt, and family responsibilities. The suicide rate in this age group remains the highest, documented at 27 per 100,000 in 2021 (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025), reflecting the crushing weight of provider strain.
Marriage & FatherhoodThe pressure to fulfill an idealized, often financially demanding, role without the cultural permission to express fear or vulnerability, leading to greater psychological distress.

Common Warning Signs: What to Watch For

Unlike women, whose mental distress may manifest as classic symptoms of depression or anxiety, men often present with externalizing symptoms—behaviours deemed more “masculine” and less like “weakness.” Recognizing these non-traditional signs is crucial for intervention.

The Mask of Anger and Avoidance

In place of overt sadness, distress in men frequently presents as:

  • Irritability and Anger: Increased aggression, sudden outbursts, or chronic short temper (Kalpana Srivastava, 2024).
  • Substance Misuse: Turning to alcohol, drugs, or excessive smoking as a form of self-medication to cope with bottled-up emotions (Kalpana Srivastava, 2024). Men are two to three times more likely to misuse drugs than women globally (SAMHSA, 2018).
  • Withdrawal and Isolation: A significant reduction in social interaction, abandoning hobbies, or extreme self-reliance that pushes away support, rooted in the belief that seeking help is a sign of failure.
  • Risk-Taking Behaviour: Engaging in reckless or dangerous activities, reflecting a greater suicidal intent and often leading to higher rates of completion compared to women (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).

The Stark Reality: Suicide Statistics in India

The NCRB data reveals a harrowing picture of the crisis:

  • Gender Disparity: The male-to-female suicide ratio in India stands at approximately 2.5:1 (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).
  • Global Share: In 2021, around 25% of male suicides globally occurred in India, highlighting the country’s severe burden of this epidemic (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).
  • Rising Toll: The total number of male suicides in India surged by over one-third between 2014 and 2021 (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025), with the figure exceeding 122,000 in 2022 (NCRB, 2022).

Why Don’t Men Seek Help?

The disparity between mental illness prevalence and help-seeking behaviour among men is largely attributable to significant systemic and social barriers.

Stigma and Self-Stigma

The primary barrier is stigma. Adherence to traditional masculinity norms is overwhelmingly shown to stigmatize mental health help-seeking (Milner et al., 2018).

  • Internalised Guilt: Men often experience self-stigma, where they view their depression or anxiety as a personal failure to measure up to the masculine standard of toughness and emotional control (YRG Care). This sense of guilt and shame is a powerful deterrent to admitting a problem.
  • Fear of Labeling: Many men hesitate to seek professional help for fear of being labelled as “weak,” “unstable,” or “mad” by their family, friends, and employers.

Accessibility Barriers: Rural vs. Urban

While mental health awareness is gradually increasing in metropolitan areas, significant gaps exist in accessibility and perception across the country.

  • Lack of Services: In many rural and impoverished communities, where the stress on agricultural workers and daily-wage earners is highest, mental health services are either non-existent or inadequate (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).
  • Method of Coping: Rural men often resort to lethal and easily accessible means for suicide, such as pesticide poisoning, which further contributes to the high completion rates, a pattern noted in various studies (Dalia C, Satishchandra K, 2025).
  • Perception: Urban centres may have a higher concentration of psychologists and psychiatrists, but even here, the influence of masculinity ideals means men are disproportionately underrepresented in client populations and often drop out of treatment prematurely (NCBI, 2020).

Voices of Change: Recent Progress and Advocacy

The tide is slowly turning, driven by visible advocacy and dedicated government initiatives. Recognising and accepting the higher rate of suicide in men is the first and utmost important step towards respecting male mental health (Guneet Kaur Arora, 2024).

The Role of Public Platforms and Peer Support

  • Destigmatisation through Dialogue: Public figures and campaigns have begun to openly challenge the strictures of toxic masculinity. This creates a much-needed “popular discourse” that elevates a healthier, more emotionally integrated version of manhood (The Swaddle, 2021).
  • Challenging the Façade: Efforts are being made to encourage men to reveal the “hidden 10%” of their identity—the vulnerable, non-masculine aspects they keep close to their hearts—by showcasing positive role models who have stopped “performing” traditional masculinity and been rewarded for their authenticity (The Swaddle, 2021).
  • Rise of Digital Support: The success of platforms like Tele-MANAS, which is catering to over 1,300 calls per day in 20 languages and links callers to specialist care, highlights a demand for anonymous, accessible support (PIB, 2023).

The Positive Masculinity Framework

Academic and psychological discourse is moving beyond simply “dismantling” toxic norms toward building a framework for Positive Psychology/Positive Masculinity (PPPM) (ResearchGate, 2021). This emerging framework aims to define and encourage healthy, emotionally expressive, and supportive ways of being a man, offering a constructive path forward rather than focusing solely on prohibition.

Expert Tips & Support Resources

Addressing men’s mental health requires a multi-pronged approach: professional help, individual coping strategies, and community support.

Actionable Mental Wellness Strategies

  1. Acknowledge the Signs: Men must learn to re-frame discomfort. Irritability, sleeplessness, and increased drinking are not “bad moods”; they are often the language of underlying depression or anxiety.
  2. Speak Up (The “How are you, really?” approach): Men need to actively cultivate deeper friendships centred on emotional exchange, rather than just activity (YRG Care). Ask a male friend, “How are you, really?” and genuinely wait for the answer.
  3. Seek Professional Support: Reframe therapy not as defeat, but as courageous self-maintenance. If you would not ignore a broken leg, do not ignore a stressed mind (YRG Care). Therapy is an act of responsibility to one’s family and oneself.
  4. Embrace Vulnerability: Practice emotional expression with a trusted partner or friend. This can involve simple acts like naming feelings (“I feel stressed about work”) instead of externalising them as anger.

National Helplines and Initiatives in India

Many excellent, confidential helplines are available, often in multiple Indian languages. These services offer free, immediate support for anyone in distress, including men struggling with financial stress, relationship issues, or suicidal thoughts.

Helpline NameNumberService DescriptionAvailability
Tele-MANAS (Govt. of India)14416 or 1-800-891-4416National Tele Mental Health Programme; free counselling and linkage to specialists.24/7, 20+ Languages
KIRAN (Govt. of India)1800-599-0019Mental Health Rehabilitation Helpline; first-aid, psychological support, distress management.24/7, 13 Languages
Vandrevala Foundation+91 9999 666 555Crisis Intervention Helpline; free mental health support and psychological counselling.24/7, 365 Days
One Life78930-78930Suicide Prevention & Crisis Support.7 days a week
Jeevan Aastha Helpline1800 233 3330Suicide Prevention and Mental Health Counseling.24/7
Mann Talks+91 8686 139 139Counselling support.Varies, generally extended hours
Tripta Foundation+91 90284 13439Mental Health Counseling. Addiction CounsellingRegular work hours

Conclusion: A Call to Action for a Healthier Masculinity

The critical state of male mental health in India is a crisis rooted in the systemic suppression of vulnerability and the unrelenting weight of patriarchal expectations. The statistics—particularly the disproportionately high rates of male suicide—are a clarion call that we can no longer afford to ignore.

The solution lies not in simply asking men to be different, but in fundamentally changing the environments that punish vulnerability. This requires a collective effort to dismantle harmful gender expectations, particularly the toxic and emotionally restrictive concept that strength is the absence of feeling. True strength lies in the courage to face one’s emotions, communicate distress, and seek help.

We call upon:

  • Families to break the generational pattern of emotional suppression by normalising open conversations and emotional check-ins, allowing boys and men to feel without judgment.
  • Workplaces and Educational Institutions to implement mental health first-aid training and foster cultures where seeking support for stress is viewed as responsible, not weak.
  • Policy Makers to continue strengthening public, accessible mental health infrastructure, like Tele-MANAS, ensuring that quality care reaches urban and rural populations alike.

By fostering a culture where asking for help is considered courageous, we can begin to heal the silent wounds of a generation and ensure that Indian men are supported in achieving not just financial success, but genuine, lasting peace of mind.

DISCLAIMER

This blog post was researched and edited using AI tools to enhance content quality and accuracy. The suggestions and information provided are intended for general guidance only and should not be considered medical advice or a substitute for professional consultation. Readers are encouraged to seek help from qualified mental health professionals for any personal concerns or conditions. The content may not reflect the latest developments, and independent verification is recommended.

Leave a Reply